Topic > The Fault in Our Stars versus A Walk to Remember

A Walk Among the StarsIs the film The Fault in Our Stars a copy of the film A Walk to Remember? Many people argue that A Walk to Remember and The Fault in Our Stars are basically the same story, while others argue that they are not. Both films have their pros and cons and are similar and different. This essay will compare and contrast The Fault in Our Stars with A Walk to Remember based on their plots, settings, and endings to determine which is better. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on "Why Violent Video Games Shouldn't Be Banned"? Get an Original Essay Story plots have similarities and differences. The Fault in Our Stars, based on the book of the same name by John Green, shows its viewers the story of Hazel Grace Lancaster, who has lung cancer. Hazel meets Augustus Waters, a charming, intelligent boy her age who had osteosarcoma, a type of bone cancer, which caused him to lose a leg. Hazel feels like she'll only hurt him and tells him he's "a grenade." What she means by this is that one day she will "explode" and hurt everyone she loves, but Augustus doesn't listen to her. “All your efforts to keep me away will fail,” is what he says in response, and, even though Hazel's cancer seems to be an obstacle in their way, they can't help but fall for each other. In A Walk to Remember, based on the novel of the same name by Nicholas Sparks, the protagonist, Landon Carter, meets Jamie Sullivan, a very reserved girl whose father is the reverend of the church, and asks her for help because he needs to rehearse for a theater show at their school, which he was forced to attend due to his criminal behavior. Jamie tells him that he will help him on one condition. “You have to promise not to fall in love with me,” he says. Jamie was trying to warn Landon not to fall in love with her, just like Hazel did with Augustus, but Landon dismisses Jamie's comment and tells her he would never do that. Unlike Hazel and Augustus, Landon and Jamie were not immediately attracted to each other, which is one of the major differences between the films. Another difference would be that Landon is healthy, while Hazel is not, meaning that Hazel has a battle with her body, and Landon does not. One similarity, though, would be that both Jamie and Hazel warned Landon and Augustus about falling for them, and neither of them listened. Landon ends up falling in love with Jamie, but what Landon doesn't know is that she has leukemia, and that's why she was trying to keep him away. This also happens in The Fault in Our Stars, where Augustus admits that he still has cancer and that he has gotten stronger. Both films show how unexpected revelations make the protagonists suffer. Hazel and Landon don't know how to react to their lovers' confessions. In the end, both Hazel and Landon decide to overcome obstacles by being brave and never abandoning their partners. Both storylines are beautiful and show viewers how love conquers all, even if unexpected events sometimes make them lose hope. In this respect it would be a tie, because both stories contain wonderful messages, which makes their plot equally wonderful. The setting of both stories is quite different. The Fault in Our Stars is set in Indianapolis, but not in regular Indianapolis. Hazel grew up in "sick" Indianapolis, which is just another way of saying that most of the places she and Augustus visit are hospitals, support groups, and other places that kids with cancer typically go to. Much of the film is set in Amsterdam, a bittersweet setting. It's bittersweet.