Topic > A Comparative Analysis of Ethnicity, Politics, and Poverty, in Modern America by Jd Vance and Ta Nehisi

The two authors Ta-Nehesi Coates and JD Vance have very similar views within their racial perspectives. Coates speaks on behalf of poor black Americans and essentially the overwhelming feelings of most African Americans. Vance, on the other hand, speaks for Trump supporters, especially America's consistently ignored white working class. Although the two speakers are on two radically different spectrums, their views and goals for helping their communities are quite similar and could be addressed simultaneously in public policy. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on "Why Violent Video Games Shouldn't Be Banned"? Get an original essay Ta-Nehesi Coates' point in his book Between the World and Me is clear: low-income African Americans suffer their current conditions due to systemic racism. Coates delves deeply into the institutions that hold blacks back, such as “police departments [that] were given the authority to destroy [their] bodies” (9). Due to the constant violence against Black bodies, African Americans, particularly those living in harsher environments, are in a constant state of fear. Older generations teach them to defend themselves, but the fine line between “being too violent” and “not being violent enough” could still cost them the same thing: their body (28). Low-income Black people aren't the only ones struggling with systemic racism. Even financially well-off African Americans continue to suffer microaggressions from ignorant white Americans and must continue to work harder than their white peers, regardless of their economic status (90). Later in the novel Coates describes a frightening experience with his son, the novel for which the book was written. Even though he was no longer in the 'battlefield' known as West Baltimore, he still witnessed a threat to "invoke [the] right over [his] son's body." Overall, Coates is not only a spokesperson for poor black people struggling with severe economic problems, but also for the entire black community as they all face the same problems resulting from cultural and systemic racism. JD Vance presents similar but different arguments than Coates in his interview article. , “Trump: Tribune of the Poor Whites.” With the rise of “factories shipping jobs overseas,” many jobs that the American working class had previously held were no longer available in the American labor market. It was this base that Trump exploited to recruit white working class votes as “his apocalyptic tone matches their lived experiences on the ground.” Likewise, for some of the issues faced in the black community, most children in the poor white community “will live in multiple homes over the course of their lives, experiencing a constant cycle of growing up close to a “stepfather” just to see him abandoning family, personally knowing more drug addicts… watching family and friends get arrested, and so on.” What distinguishes these experiences from the extreme similarities faced by African Americans is how white people deal with their difficulties. When white Americans lack so many economic resources, the main and only thing they have managed to hold on to is their “heritage and culture.” Vance, highlighting the great South American pride of Trump supporters, explains that “A large portion of the white working class has deep roots in Appalachia, and the culture of Scots-Irish honor is alive and well.” Furthermore, he argues that. 2017.